Removing barriers and challenges faced by SMEs to unlock their economic potential

Research conducted among Small and Medium Enterprises (SME) in Gauteng in 2008 identified the urgent need to address the systemic barriers hindering the development of historically disadvantaged SMEs (HDI) in South Africa, and more specifically Gauteng. Key barriers include limited access to formal financial services, challenges in accessing finance from both formal and informal sources, inadequate awareness and use of business development services, and a lack of knowledge about regulatory requirements such as BEE legislation. To empower HDI SMEs and promote inclusive economic growth, there’s a pressing need for targeted interventions, including enhanced communication and support services, tailored training programs, and the development of accessible knowledge-sharing platforms. By addressing these challenges, policymakers and stakeholders can create an enabling environment where SMEs can thrive and contribute significantly to the economy. Fifteen years down the road, I wonders what has changed.

In 2008, research showed the significant progress in democratic consolidation and economic growth over the past decade, transitioning from a tumultuous pre-1994 era to a model of democracy and economic stability. How quickly things change with South Africa again facing significant challenges in its democracy and continued lack of economic growth.Despite the advancements prior to 2008 and even now, challenges persist, particularly concerning economic inequality, and sustainable development. A coherent strategy was and is essential to address these priorities, underpinned by sound research and stakeholder involvement, including international donors that have and continue to play a pivotal role in supporting South Africa’s development goals. The research in 2008 underscored the pivotal role that SMEs play in the economy, with policies and initiatives that aimed at fostering their growth but highlighting challenges such as limited access to finance persisting in the sector.

The survey results of the 2006 FinScope Small Business were analysed to identify areas where focus group interviews could be realized among historically disadvantaged small business owners in Gauteng with an annual turnover exceeding R200,000. By spatializing the survey data in GIS, the research team was able to target areas with the highest concentration of SMEs, leading to focus groups being arranged in various locations across Gauteng. Recruiters systematically approached potential participants, ensuring they met specific selection criteria, including being historically disadvantaged business owners with the requisite turnover. Over 100 SME participants were recruited to participate in the focus group discussions that were facilitated using a structured discussion guide. The study results provided invaluable insights into the realities faced by the sample of historically disadvantaged SMEs in Gauteng.

Navigating Financial Barriers: Challenges and Solutions for SMEs

Research on financial business development services (FBDS) showed the actual uptake of services from various providers, including government agencies was low due to communication barriers, lengthy processes, and perceived inefficiencies in service delivery. SMEs expressed a strong need for financial support, bookkeeping services, assistance with business plans, and practical training in areas such as marketing and financial management. They highlighted difficulties in accessing support, including bureaucratic hurdles and lack of proximity to service providers. SMEs highlighted the need for improving communication, providing simplified information materials, offering sector-specific mentoring programs, and coordinating FBDS provision more effectively across sectors. The findings underscored the importance of addressing the specific needs and constraints of historically disadvantaged SMEs in accessing and benefiting from financial support and advisory services.

When it came to accessing financing from formal and informal institutions in Gauteng, the research revealing a complex landscape marked by obstacles such as poor financial literacy, stringent bank requirements, and limited access to collateral being a barrier. While SMEs emphasized the vital role of financing for their growth and operational needs, including stock procurement and workspace improvements, the reality of obtaining loans proved daunting. Despite some SMEs resorting to personal savings, bonds, or assistance from friends and family, the overarching sentiment is one of frustration with the system, as articulated by one business owner “…we are always short of cash flow. The more money you have, the more stock you can buy. In a business, you can never have enough money.” The research underscored the need for clearer communication and simplified application processes, particularly for historically disadvantaged SMEs, along with the importance of initiatives to enhance financial literacy and access to collateral.

SMEs reported that many SMEs still struggled to secure loans, facing stringent requirements such as providing three months’ worth of bank statements and being told to return later, sometimes after six months, without clear explanations for loan refusals. This was despite working with consultants in filling out applications. Some participants expressed a desire for institutions to visit their premises to better understand their businesses, highlighting a reliance on paperwork over understanding the business’s context and potential. Participants were of the opinions that financial institutions had racial and cultural biases in their banking relationships, particularly among historically disadvantaged SMEs. While banks were viewed as trustworthy, there was a widespread frustration with the difficulty in obtaining loans, leading many to seek funding from informal sources or rely on personal savings. Recommendations made to address deficiencies in both demand and supply sides, emphasized the need for improved financial literacy, more flexible lending practices, better communication from financial institutions, and a deeper understanding of cultural differences to foster more inclusive access to finance for SMEs.

Research on the legal structure of SMEs showed that many, particularly those with larger turnovers, opted for legal structures like Closed Corporations (CCs) or sole proprietorships to access finance and government contracts. However, there was a general lack of awareness regarding the benefits of formal registration. SMEs expressed frustration with the inaccessibility and perceived ineffectiveness of public institutions, highlighting the need for better communication and support tailored to their needs. Additionally, there was a widespread lack of understanding of BEE legislation, with many SMEs feeling excluded from its benefits. While some participated in business associations, a sentiment was expressed that these groups often failed to advocate effectively for SME interests. Recommendations included improved information dissemination, training, and research to address the challenges faced by SMEs in navigating the legal and regulatory environment.

Empowering SMEs Through Knowledge Sharing and Collaboration

Despite acknowledging the importance of knowledge sharing, SMEs often lacked effective forums and time to engage in such activities, relying primarily on previous work experience for learning. Suggestions for improvement included creating handbooks and organizing workshops tailored to SME needs, with government support in disseminating information and facilitating training. Additionally, there were calls for enhanced ICT access and utilization, particularly through radio and television programs and the development of a knowledge portal to centralize resources and facilitate networking among SMEs. One participant said “We never come across it at all,” referring to the perceived absence of cultural, identity, and religious influences in financial sector assistance, reflecting the complex dynamics faced by SMEs in accessing support and knowledge.

In conclusion the study emphasized the importance of small business owners taking responsibility for their own growth and development while also calling for collaboration among stakeholders including government, financial institutions, and the private sector. Among the recommendations were the need for more effective communication and awareness-building regarding FBDS, improved access to finance for small businesses, enhanced training and support for legal and regulatory matters, and the establishment of a knowledge portal to facilitate information sharing and learning among SMEs. Reflecting on the challenges faced by small business owners in accessing finance, one respondent remarked, “I don’t think it is based on colour, it is based on risk but they don’t go to the level where they explain to you what makes you a high risk.” This underscores the reality of what SMEs to this day face when seeking access to finance especially from formal institutions, “you are too high a risk”. It would seem that financial institutions will use whatever means to create barriers in financing SMEs rather than put any effort into understanding their needs and facilitating growth in the sector. I was reminded by Brene Brown the author of “Daring to Lead” that at the end of the day corporates are where the money is for the financial institutions and that small business are merely a nuisance that they have to unfortunately deal with.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.